Reflections of a Wine Business Blogger

“Sometimes I lie awake at night, and ask, ‘Where have I gone wrong?’ Then a voice says to me, ‘This is going to take more than one night.’”

Charles M. Schultz

The Decision to Write

As my eyes opened on the morning of January 1, 2010, I realized that I had survived what Time Magazine described as ‘The Decade from Hell.’ Oh, a bit beaten-up and feeling a little like one of John Stewart’s Black Pig Meats salumis at the end of the sausage making process. Yes, the economic events of the past 10 years have put most of us through the grinder, but here we are at the other end, having survived to make, market and sell wine another day. A little more than 9 months ago, I started writing the Think Wine Marketing blog. My timing coincided with the bottom of the business cycle. In short order the US stock market had lost more than half it’s value, ending March ’09 with a Dow Jones Market index below 6,500. Housing values, the base of asset wealth for most consumers continued to decline in all but a handful of smaller SMSA’s. Credit to small businesses had been so severely constricted as to be non-existent, especially for wineries with slow moving, devalued inventories. Times were tough for the wine industry. Before this recession, now called ‘The Great Recession,’ the wine industry has always been considered to be recession proof; but, this time at best our industry has proven to be recession resilient. Several cultural and structural changes were accelerated by the difficult economic times that had direct effects on wine sales. As consumers rushed to reduce credit card debit and increase their rate of savings , a significant downward segment shift hit wine pricing almost overnight. The pressures on pricing and the shift from fine dining to a more casual food experience with an emphasis on value, led to a rapid change in channel strategy for many wineries. The rapid movement from an on-premise focus to retail distribution had eviscerated any pricing leverage that formerly not sold at retail wineries had displayed, squeezing profits and/or creating negative margin sales. In light of the current times I decided to write a blog focused on wine marketing. A blog that in part told stories that would be of some help to smaller family wineries in these difficult times. I took a Socratic approach of creating a central narrative and then providing a workbook like ending. As I look back over the last 3 quarters of 2009, and look forward to 2010, I hope that I’ve helped provide some positive mentoring to at least a few family winecos out there in the ether.

The Metric System

While never concerned about gross numbers as the sole metric of success, as an experienced marketer I do track the number of hits and reads that the Think Wine Marketing blog receives. However, my primary concern is/and has been just who is it that reads my blog. It is specifically wine industry marketing centric. My readers for the most part, based on comments and emails are winery principals, GMs, CMOs, PR directors and brand managers. Based on blog originated emails, which have outpaced blog comments by a factor of 10, the TWM blog also has a demonstrable following in finance and in tech. I’ve written 33 blog post in nine months, that have received 149,117 hits of which 56,321 (37.8%) were a result of search engine crawlers, resulting in a net of 92,796 reads, numbers easily exceeded by experienced wine writer/bloggers like Tom Wark, Alder Yarrow and Steve Heimhoff in just a few months – with the following think pieces being the top 10 posts – re. close of business on 1/6/2010.

2009 Top Ten TWM Posts

  1. Nov 17            7,475   — Doctor Pinot’s Thanksgiving
  2. Oct 7               7,434   — Revisiting Marketing 101
  3. Nov 4              7,126   — A Conversation about marketing wine online w/Paul Mabray
  4. Sep 17             6,956  — Marketing by Pulling Corks
  5. Oct 20            6,334  — The Conversation
  6. Sep 24            6,165   — Does your winery have an effective OND plan?
  7. Aug 26           4,534   — Dispatches from Wine Country
  8. Dec 23           4,430   — Y2K10: Part Two: late 90’s tech effect on wine ecommerce
  9. Jul 27             4,259   — Dispatches from the 2009 Wine Bloggers Conference
  10. Sep 9              3,860  — Wine Brand Building Focus

Beyond noting that I have loyal readers, who have provided significant support, input and feed back, the fact that the Think Wine Marketing blog has received recognition from the wine industry and in the wine press is gratifying.

That Was the Year That Was

  1. The March 2009 acquisition of Scrugy by Cruvee in early March 2009 by CEO/Founder, Evan Cover. Scrugy Founder and Chief Technology Officer, James Jory joins Cruvee as V.P. of Technology.
  2. The Think Wine Marketing Blog is launched on March 26, 2009 with the post ‘Viral Marketing Strategies for Wine Businesses.’
  3. The State of the Wine Industry Social Media’, by VinTank, Derek Bromley and Tom Wark published 5/6/2009 and available for download on the VinTank web site. IMHO this is and will be considered the foundation document of the wine industry’s involvement in the social media movement.
  4. American Canyon based wine shipping and fulfillment company New Vine Logistics suspended business operations on May 29th, 2009. The story was broken on Twitter by Larry Chandler, aka LarrytheWineGuy.
  5. The 2009 Wine Bloggers Conference at the Flamingo Resort in Santa Rosa, CA the last week of July, 2009. This was not only a well planned and executed conference, but the opportunity to meet so many wicked, smart citizen bloggers was amazing. Kudos to Joel Vincent and the Open Wine Consortium.
  6. The August 13th appointment of Think Wine Marketing founder John Corcoran (that’s me) to the Board of Advisors at Cruvee.com, a wine business intelligence platform.
  7. On August 25th, Des Moines Iowa environmental attorney Charles Becker publishes ‘Wine and Global Warming: An open letter to the President.’
  8. RJ’s Wine Blog names the TWM blog of the Month for September 2009. If you’re not reading the frequent posts from Avenue A/Razorfish alum, R.J. Hilgers, please click on the link to check this A-List wine blog.
  9. On September 11th The Wine Spectator Senior Editor James Laube reports that cult Pinot Noir producer Kosta Browne sells for a reported $40 million.
  10. On September 28, Williams-Sonoma Founder Chuck Williams speaks on the lessons of customer service at Sonoma’s Maysonnave House.
  11. On September 29th, Wine Business Monthly publishes, as a cover lead, TWM author John Corcoran’s CRM, sales force automation article.
  12. On October 5th, the online wine magazine Palate Press published Paul Mabray’s article ‘New VinTank Research Analyses Wine iPhone Apps‘, winning praise for both wine consumers and the wine/tech segment of the wine industry.
  13. On October 25th Amazon suspends their on again off agin wine sales efforts. The demise of the Amazon.com wine store was laid at the feet of the arcane and balkinized labyrinth of state wine laws. Wine writer, W. Blake Gray wrote in the December 3rd post on his blog the Gray Market Report that Amazon withdrew because of taxation issues, “not just on wine but on everything.”
  14. On October 28th Cruvee & Vinfolio announce a partnership in which user generated reviews incorporated into Cruvee’s social media management platform. On November 24th Cruvee and Cellertracker announce a partnership giving Cruvee clients direct access to over 1.1 million wine reviews. This series of appointments/partnerships along with the subsequent December 3rd launch of The OwnIT movement helped to consolidate wine data and give wineries control over their brand communication. This innovative and free service from Cruvee.com was created to provide a platform “giving you control over how your wine is represented online.”
  15. On December 23rd the TWM blog received recognition from Dale Cruse and the Drinks Are On Me blog as one of the top new food and drink blogs of 2009. Bob Dwyer wrote a very nice review, which is not surprising given the quality of  writing on his blog, the Wellesley Wine Press.
  16. On December 28th Eric LeVine released a sneak peak demo of the new CellarTracker redesign.
  17. The TWM blog landed the #5 spot for the 10/7/09 post ‘Think Wine Marketing: Revisiting Wine Marketing 101′ on the 2009 Most Visited Blog Postings List on Winebusiness.com.

Observable Lessons

Dear Reader, I hope that my blog posts helped you to imagine ways to develop not only a sustainable wine business model but to envision more innovative route to market strategies and branding initiatives for 2010 and beyond. 2009 was a year that presented significant challenges to wine businesses regardless of size or location. It is my experience that out of chaos comes innovation. Observations that I’ve made over time that the Great Recession tended to reconfirm are: Identify your strengths and outsource functional areas in which you don’t do well; Hire and retain talent; Understand, even in an age of social media, that you own and are responsible for your brand(s) reputation; Understand that wine marketing is more than price reductions and promotions; Diversify your channel strategies; Rethink three tier distribution and investigate DTC (as more than tasting room sales) and DTT solutions to include digital distribution; Incorporate the appropriate sales and marketing focused technologies such as CRMs; Convert your wine business from a production centric culture to a sales and marketing focused culture. It’s now time to roll up your sleeves, and to focus efforts on driving your wine businesses to success in the new year, and in the new decade.

Note: Copyright © 2010 Think Wine Marketing® All rights reserved.

7 thoughts on “Reflections of a Wine Business Blogger

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Reflections of a Wine Business Blogger « Think Wine Marketing -- Topsy.com

  2. Pingback: Reflections of a Wine Business Blogger (Cork) with an OwnIT shout out! « OwnIT

    • Thank you. I’m pleased that my blog has found a small, but focused readership, and that in this circle of readers some value is derived. BTW: I’ve always impressed w/the wines from Argentina, but I came away from this past Thursday, Jan. 28 online tasting with Vines of Mendoza a bigger fan than ever. It is no surprise that the category “Argentinian Wines’ is doing so well in the USA marketplace.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s